The Budget has set the country on the wrong path - Yorkshire Post Letters

From: Gordon Lawrence, Sheffield.

What a good read Geoffrey Brooking gave us on Letters, December 2. We are taken on a flight amongst myriads of cuckoos in his enthralling assessment of Rachel Reeves November budget.

He speaks of all the fabulous things gifted by Rachel to the bottom 90 per cent of the UK population in her strenuous efforts to escape widening denunciation and, perhaps, the sack.

She must have been caught up in a rose-coloured cloud since a fair percentage of the top 10 per cent have had enough and have already flitted with most of their remaining wealth as the freezing of income tax thresholds and various other growth destroying taxes such as the National Insurance charge have bitten deep into the victims of her earlier dalliances with the tax system.

Chancellor Rachel Reeves poses outside 11 Downing Street, London, with her ministerial red box. PIC: Stefan Rousseau/PA Wireplaceholder image
Chancellor Rachel Reeves poses outside 11 Downing Street, London, with her ministerial red box. PIC: Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire

And now, her response to that previous damage is to plough on regardless of incorporating all the Labour-pleasing left-wing orthodoxies that will, as before, get us nowhere.

We are now eating into the lower percentiles as total tax revenues contract. The top 10 per cent contribute about 50 per cent of total income tax and the remaining 90 per cent will suffer as Rachel pours what largesse she can scrape out on to the lower orders, a large fraction who contribute little to the overall economic revenues and living standards of the country.

How many, especially the left-wing readers of our paper like Geoffrey, think we are the sixth richest nation in the world. They certainly trot it out as they talk with the abandon of billionaires on a public spending spree. Well, no we are not the 6th: we are 26th based on the relevant income per head measure and our descent is very worrying,

Visions of yellow fruit may be an exaggeration but living in cloud cuckoo land will seriously impair our offspring’s future. Geoffrey’s eulogies will not even impress the crows on his flights of fancy.

My final advice for Geoffrey Brooking is to compare Starmer’s manifesto with the egregious scenario that British workers, so extolled in the manifesto and glib Labour persuasion, are faced with on a daily basis.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice