The world does not just revolve around farmers - Yorkshire Post Letters
From: J H Braham, Huddersfield.
What an unfortunate article Sarah Todd wrote in Saturday’s Yorkshire Post 29/11/25. It was called an essay, but it didn’t offer any intellectual value or critical analysis, so opinion piece is a more appropriate descriptor. It was titled ‘Awful Labour are envy-driven’.
I read on expecting some explanation of the concept of ‘envy’, perhaps some justification for the use of the word ‘envious’. What exactly is the ‘awful Labour’ government envious of?
Instead, I read a judgmental tirade full of invective. There was no logical thread; we just jumped from one subject she despises to another. She lumps together all sponging benefit recipients who have more than two children, pro-Palestine protestors, transgender children and people who complain about mud on the road and who unlike her wouldn’t know a day's work if it didn’t hit them in the face. The article made me ashamed of my farming roots.


In the opinion piece Sarah Todd presents herself as a hard-working, thrifty, salt of the earth person as if that descriptor can only belong to people who live in rural communities. She then informs readers that not only was she able to buy her own house at 29 (because she grafted and saved) but also had a ‘lady from the village’ to come in as her cleaner/home help and babysitter and in addition employ someone to do her ironing.
She paid them a ‘bit of cash to top up their pension, a few crisp notes on the side’. Part of the ask no questions pay no tax brigade I suppose? She makes snide comments about people who are ‘doled out’ state benefits. Does my ‘winter fuel allowance’ qualify as a state handout, or something that as a pensioner I am entitled to even though I can afford to live without it?
She despises what she describes as ‘a cabinet of townies’, ‘metropolitan elite with their off-lead dogs’ but fawns at members of the monarchy who apparently intrinsically understand farming in the Yorkshire Dales.
Don’t tell me, King Charles had to take out a second mortgage to send his children to university? Her comment that protesting farmers have been treated less favourably than pro-Palestine protestors suggests she has no idea that 2,300 peaceful pro-Palestine protestors have been arrested under the Terrorism Act for carrying placards. They were protesting about genocide not taxation.
The article is a badly written rant which lacks clarity and cohesion and which casts people who live in rural communities as being self-centred and self-important, which they are not. Farmers are part of this world, but this world does not revolve around just them.
