Developer appeals against refusal of 600-home plan on Yorkshire farmland

A developer has submitted an appeal against the refusal of its plans for up to 600 homes in Yarm, and has called for a public inquiry.

Taylor Wimpey saw Stockton Council’s planning committee reject its £133m outline proposal for up to 600 homes on land east of Holdenfields Farm, Green Lane, Yarm in a packed meeting last month.

The plans had attracted almost 600 objections and sparked a petition opposing housing developments in Yarm with over 3,200 signatures.

Residents raised issues including the impact on roads, congestion, Yarm High Street, heritage, schools and medical practices, saying the “infrastructure cannot support this capacity” and it would cause “chaos”.

A satellite map of the site where Taylor Wimpey proposes to build up to  600 homes in Yarm. Picture: Taylor Wimpey.placeholder image
A satellite map of the site where Taylor Wimpey proposes to build up to 600 homes in Yarm. Picture: Taylor Wimpey.

Taylor Wimpey said the scheme would bring “substantial and material benefits” including £85m into the economy and more than 200 jobs.

Planning officers recommended approving the plan, saying the weight of public objection was irrelevant and traffic impacts were not considered severe, but councillors on the decision-making planning committee decided to refuse it.

One member, deputy council leader Councillor Paul Rowling, said: “There has to be a time where we actually say no.”

Councillors told why they could not support the plan, speaking of already “horrific” traffic problems, lack of capacity and electricity supply, and the effects on wildlife, woodland and countryside. Now, the developer has put in an appeal against the decision.

Petition campaigner and Yarm town councillor Yvonne Wallace on True Lovers' Walk, Yarm, in front of Yarm Viaduct.placeholder image
Petition campaigner and Yarm town councillor Yvonne Wallace on True Lovers' Walk, Yarm, in front of Yarm Viaduct.

It submitted a statement of its case to Stockton Council’s planning portal this week, via consultants ELG Planning. It says it “considers that it is important for the appeal to be heard by way of public inquiry”, to test evidence through questioning from an advocate and hear of complex issues in a case which drew “substantial local interest”.

The statement says: “The appellant wishes to cross-examine the council’s witnesses. The planning application has generated huge public interest with over 500 objections made to the proposed development from local residents, the parish and town councils.

“The appellant’s evidence will demonstrate that the appeal site is a deliverable proposition, and is located in a strong market area meaning it can come forward in the short term making a material contribution to housing land supply in the borough.”

It argues the council does not have five years’ worth of housing land and its Local Plan which sets out planning priorities is out of date, so the delivery of the homes, in an area facing an affordable homes crisis, “should be given substantial weight”. It contends planning permission should be granted unless there is a strong reason to refuse it to protect areas or assets, or the harms would outweigh the benefits.

It says Yarm is “an appropriate settlement”, the site is a “sustainable location” and the amount of homes is “relatively modest”. It also argues the development would be in-keeping with the area’s character and “would not have an unacceptable impact on the character and distinctiveness of Yarm”.

The developer also disagrees with reasons for refusing the plan covering landscape, biodiversity, ecology, protected species, roads and infrastructure. It asserts the proposal will bring benefits including green areas, bus services and cycle connections, which will not be outweighed by “limited” impacts.

Yarm town councillor Yvonne Wallace, who started the petition and spoke against the plans at the original committee meeting, said: “I’m disappointed but not surprised. It would be too much to expect them to just drop it. I suppose it’s not entirely unexpected.

“We just have to deal with things as and when they happen. I’ll just continue with it in much the same manner I have done since last May,

“We’ll be having some meetings. I want to be there at the appeal hearing definitely, I think a lot of people will want to be there.”

A Taylor Wimpey spokesperson said: “We were disappointed that our proposals for a new community/development at Green Lane, Yarm were refused. We will continue to work closely with Stockton Council and local stakeholders as part of the planning appeal process.”

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice