Charlie Johnston critical of Southwell’s prize hike for Constitution Hill appearance
Middleham trainer Charlie Johnston has said he is “not impressed” by the £40,000 put up for Constitution Hill’s planned Flat debut on Friday when others race through the winter on the all-weather for “derisory” prize money.
The multiple Grade One-winning former Champion Hurdle winner has suffered a disastrous sequence of three falls in four races, prompting trainer Nicky Henderson to announce plans to run the horse on the Flat, to see if he could regain his confidence and form ahead of a possible return to Cheltenham.
It led to the mile-and-a-half contest at Southwell being brought forward and prize money being hugely increased by bookmaker SBK to create the joint most valuable novice race to be run on the all-weather in Britain.
But Johnston, writing in his stable’s monthly magazine, the Kingsley Klarion, was critical of the way the race has been upgraded.


He is also sceptical connections can learn much from any potential run by Constitution Hill at the Nottinghamshire track next Friday evening as part of Arena Racing Company’s (ARC) new Friday Night Live initiative, aimed at attracting new spectators to the sport and screened by ITV Racing.
Johnston wrote: “Like everyone else, I'm fascinated to see if Constitution Hill makes his Flat debut at Southwell on February 20 as part of their Friday Night Live card.
"It's hard to see how his performance in what amounts to a glorified bumper will guide connections as to whether/how he might perform in the Champion Hurdle.
“If he runs, he should definitely attract more viewers, but what annoys me, however, is that trainers who support racing on the all-weather circuit throughout the winter have to watch their horses compete for derisory prize-money on a daily basis, yet the prospect of including Constitution Hill has seen the race brought forward from another Southwell card and, remarkably, the addition of £40,000 in prize-money, making the race the joint most valuable novice race to be run on the all-weather in Britain.
"I'm not impressed."
There’s little doubt Constitution Hill’s planned Flat debut has attracted a great deal of publicity for the sport regardless of the extra prize money and a huge crowd is expected at Southwell for a race given an extra boost when Henderson announced the nine-year-old would be ridden by champion jockey Oisin Murphy.
One person who is certainly happy with the race and prize money on offer is the all-conquering trainer Willie Mullins.
The Master of Closutton says he is giving serious consideration to fielding a runner in the race which would likely end hopes of a Henderson walkover.
He said: “I think every trainer will be trying to find something and of course we’ll have something for it.
“It’s a £40,000 maiden, of course I’m thinking of running something in it. We’re giving it some thought. I’ve got a couple in mind, but I haven’t spoken to the owners. It will be good craic.
“It’s going to create a lot of positive publicity for racing and I think it is fine to do. I don’t see any negatives. I might even go, you never know.”
Henderson is sure Constitution Hill is “still as good as he was two years ago” – but admits “there’s a lot of water to go under the bridge” before he commits to another Champion Hurdle challenge.
But he is happy to see his stable star return to action.
“It’ll just do him good and it will do us all good if it goes right. You can see why we are doing it, he’s got to have a race,” Henderson told talkSPORT 2.
“We don’t know if he’ll run in the Champion Hurdle, we really don’t. We’ve been doing loads of jumping with him and it is perfectly possible that he’ll go.
“I’ve no doubt he’s still as good as he was two years ago. His work is as good as it has ever been, which is why we can do this on the Flat.
"A mile and a half will be ideal for him.”
