Water tank repair ‘often overlooked’ before replacement, specialist warns
Roger Line, founder and CEO of Structural Repairs, says water companies should establish whether existing structures can be safely repaired before committing to demolition and rebuilding, which can be costly and unnecessary
Ofwat is due to decide next month on additional funding for priority assets, including service reservoirs, contact tanks and wastewater settlement tanks. Its draft decisions, published in August, proposed £3.4 billion in extra allowances for 13 companies in England and Wales, covering asset health alongside other areas such as growth.


But according to Roger Line, founder and CEO of Structural Repairs, ageing concrete does not automatically mean a tank needs replacing. Before committing to demolition and rebuilding, he said, water companies should establish whether the existing structure can be safely repaired and how much useful life it could provide.
He said: “Asset owners can see a leak, a crack or a damaged surface, but that rarely tells the whole story. They can’t necessarily see what is happening inside the concrete.
“Scanning and other investigations can identify hidden defects, show the condition of the reinforcement and establish how far the deterioration goes and what’s causing it. Without that, demolishing and replacing the structure can seem like the only answer before repair has been properly assessed.”
Scrutiny of asset conditions is growing. In June 2025, the Independent Water Commission’s interim findings said there was not sufficient understanding of the health of the industry’s pipes, treatment plants and pumping stations. In England, the Government’s water White Paper promises “MOT” checks on infrastructure. Ofwat has also consulted on a licence condition requiring companies in England and Wales to show their asset management systems are fit for purpose, which it expects to take effect in 2028.
Mr Line said investigations draw on methods such as radar, ultrasonic testing and corrosion assessment, chosen to suit the structure and checked against sampling or other tests where needed. No single survey reveals everything, so any inaccessible or unassessed areas should be made clear.
He said: “The point is to turn a condition concern into a practical decision. What needs repairing? Where? How extensive is it? What would the repair involve and cost?
“That evidence lets you target the repair and avoid work that isn’t needed. It also makes costs more predictable. Where the defects, the access and the work required are well enough understood, a fixed-price repair may be possible, with the assumptions and any unforeseen conditions clearly set out.”
The right solution depends on the asset. Options include resin injection into suitable defects, reinstating damaged concrete, protecting reinforcement and engineered composite strengthening.
Where a tank has already been coated, banded or patched, Mr Line said the useful question is why the problem has continued.
He said: “The objective is to address the cause, not simply cover the visible symptoms. You need to look at the concrete and the earlier repair together.”
Once the work is complete, the repair should be checked against acceptance criteria agreed before it began. Depending on the project, that may involve repeat scanning compared with the original survey, bond testing or watertightness checks, with any shortfalls put right and checked again.
He said: “That gives the asset owner a record of the original condition, the work carried out and the evidence used to verify it.”
Repair does not suit every structure, he added.
He said: “There will be cases where retaining the structure isn’t safe, practical or economical. New construction may be the right answer where more capacity or a different process is needed.”
Retaining a suitable structure may also reduce the need for new concrete, steel, demolition and construction, supporting net-zero objectives. The benefit should be demonstrated against a realistic replacement option and include the repair’s own impacts and expected life.
He said: “Owners need a business case that brings the condition, repair scope, cost, programme, expected life and carbon comparison together. Find the hidden defects, establish what genuinely needs repairing, and give the owner a clear plan and price wherever the evidence allows. That’s how repair becomes an evidenced investment in the future of the asset.
“The first question shouldn’t be ‘do we have to demolish this?’ It should be ‘what is actually wrong, and can it be repaired?’”