'Higher' customer expectation is part of reason people think Yorkshire Water has failed, boss says

A “level of expectation from customers that’s much higher” is part of the reason that people believe Yorkshire Water is failing, the firm’s chief executive has said.

Nicola Shaw, who has come under pressure for accepting off-shore payments of £1.3m on top of her main salary, made the comments at the East Yorkshire Your Yorkshire Water, Your Say event.

The company held online question and answer sessions in each part of the region, with 93 customers taking part in discussion with Ms Shaw and other senior officials.

The chief executive was asked: “Why has Yorkshire Water failed its customers in most aspects?”

The customer cited security of supply, adequate sewage management and investment as areas where the firm was not meeting the standard.

Ms Shaw said: “It's a combination of issues that has led to the deterioration in the quality of the networks, as I've been talking about and it’s been largely driven off a desire to keep bills as low as possible for as long as possible.”

She also mentioned that “attitudes have changed”.

“People don't expect any kind of interruption, and they don't expect any kind of discharge of sewage, even when they really dilute with stormwater into rivers and into the seas.

Nicola Shaw, chief executive of Yorkshire Water.placeholder image
Nicola Shaw, chief executive of Yorkshire Water.

“So, there's a level of expectation from customers that's much higher.”

She continued: “The investment we're making at the moment is to try and respond to that, and to seriously improve on the quality of our discharges and the frequency of discharges.

“So, we’re really working to listen to what customers have said.”

But Ms Shaw added that “it does take a long time and is going to cost a lot of money”.

The comments come amid ongoing questions about Ms Shaw’s performance and the huge financial package she receives from Yorkshire Water, and its Jersey-based parent company Kelda Holdings.

The company was recently given a red rating by the Environment Agency for serious pollution incidents.

These almost tripled in 2024, with figures showing the firm has one of the worst records in the country.

Ofwat’s Water Company Performance Report has categorised Yorkshire Water as “lagging behind”. This put it in the same bracket as Thames Water and Southern Water.

These damning assessments have come at the same time as chief executive Nicola Shaw’s overall remuneration has reached more than £3m over the last two financial years.

This includes two off-shore payments of £660,000 from Kelda Holdings on top of her main salary and any bonuses.

Bills are set to increase by 41 per cent over the next five years to pay for upgrades to the water system’s creaking infrastructure, while there was a hosepipe ban for half of 2025.

In the last seven years, the company’s debt has risen from £4.2bn to £6.8bn, requiring £275m to be spent each year paying shareholders to service the interest. That puts Yorkshire Water’s debt to equity ratio at 70 per cent, which Ofwat describes as unstable.

Ms Shaw told the Q&A that while the company’s debt would continue to rise, as invested more, efforts would be made to bring the gearing down.

“Debt will increase over time because we are investing so much,” she said.

“I'm not in the world of saying debt in absolute terms is coming down, but we are intending to reduce the gearing over the whole of the five years of this investment period.

“So, relative to equity, we will have less debt, but the whole thing is growing because of the investments we're making.”

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice