People in the 'real world' will support cut to overseas aid, Yorkshire MP claims, as minister resigns over move

A Yorkshire MP has claimed that people in the “real world” will welcome a cut to overseas aid as a Foreign Office minister resigned in protest against the Government’s decision to cut the budget.

Shipley Conservative Philip Davies said he welcomed Rishi Sunak’s announcement that the aid budget will be cut to 0.5 per cent of gross national income in 2021 – in spite of promises not to reduce it in the Conservative manifesto – adding the Government’s “intention” is to return it to 0.7 per cent when the fiscal situation allows.

Mr Sunak said, while delivering the Spending Review today, that “during a domestic fiscal emergency, when we need to prioritise our limited resources on jobs and public services sticking rigidly to spending 0.7 per cent of our national income on overseas aid, is difficult to justify to the British people especially when we’re seeing the highest peacetime levels of borrowing on record”.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

He said he had “listened with great respect to those who have argued passionately to retain this target”.

Shipley Conservative MP Philip Davies. Photo: JPI MediaShipley Conservative MP Philip Davies. Photo: JPI Media
Shipley Conservative MP Philip Davies. Photo: JPI Media

But he added: “At a time of unprecedented crisis Government must make tough choices.”

But Mr Davies said in the Commons that the move would be “widely welcomed across the country in the real world, even if not always in here”.

He said: “I don't see why it should be controversial to say that we should only spend what we can afford on overseas aid and I suspect that the vast majority of the British public won't be asking why has he cut so much, they will probably be asking why are we still spending so much.”

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

But Baroness (Liz) Sugg, whose brief included sustainable development, resigned and said pledges should be kept in the “tough times as well as the good”.

In a letter to the Prime Minister, she wrote: “Many in our country face severe challenges as a result of the pandemic and I know the Government must make very difficult choices in response.

“But I believe it is fundamentally wrong to abandon our commitment to spend 0.7 per cent of gross national income on development. This promise should be kept in the tough times as well as the good.

“Given the link between our development spend and the health of our economy, the economic downturn has already led to significant cuts this year and I do not believe we should reduce our support further at a time of unprecedented global crises.”

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Boris Johnson said he was “very sorry” to receive her resignation, writing in reply that he is “extremely grateful” for her service as a minister.

“Your work has made a difference to millions of girls around the world, and will stand us in good stead for the Global Partnership for Education replenishment event next year,” he said.

“In addition, your leadership and rigour in the lead up to and during the Africa Investment Summit made it the enormous success it was.

“Your passion and commitment to your work has been clear to civil servants and your ministerial colleagues, and I know that the FCDO will miss you.”

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab added: “Liz has been a great minister and we will sorely miss her.

“She can be proud of her record championing girls’ education, promoting gender equality, supporting our Overseas Territories and the UK’s vital relations in the Caribbean. I am sorry to see her go.”

Baroness Sugg previously served as director of operations and campaigns at Downing Street under then-prime minister David Cameron before she became a Conservative life peer in 2016.

Her resignation comes amid a growing Tory backlash to the plans, as former international development secretary Andrew Mitchell warned that cutting the budget risks causing 100,000 otherwise preventable deaths.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Mr Mitchell led Conservative opposition to the policy in the Commons, and it now looks likely to face a parliamentary showdown when the expected legislation to implement the change is brought forward by the Government.

The 0.7 per cent target is written into law and Mr Johnson’s 2019 election manifesto promised to keep it.

Conservative Tobias Ellwood, the Defence Committee chairman, warned China and Russia are likely to extend their “authoritarian influence” as a result of the “vacuum” created by the UK “downgrading” its soft power programmes.

Tory Pauline Latham (Mid Derbyshire) also suggested the cut will hit education for girls and result in “more child marriages, more instances of early child birth, more FGM, more domestic violence”.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The UK will be “poorer in the eyes of the world” due to the aid cuts, Conservative former foreign secretary Jeremy Hunt added.

Outside the Commons, the Archbishop of Canterbury attacked the Government for its “shameful and wrong” cuts.

Mr Sunak said the UK’s annual aid spend from 2021 is expected to be £10bn under the temporary cut – compared to the previous figure of £15bn.

Mr Sunak said he believes the UK can “still make a difference” to the world’s poorest countries under the Government’s plans.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Oxfam chief executive Danny Sriskandarajah said: “Cutting the UK’s lifeline to the world’s poorest communities in the midst of a global pandemic will lead to tens of thousands of otherwise preventable deaths.”

While environmental and aid campaigners warned the move puts the UK’s global climate leadership at risk ahead of the United Nations Cop26 summit next year.

Funding to help poorer countries cope with climate change and development cleanly is always a key issue at the international talks.

Greenpeace UK’s head of politics, Rebecca Newsom, said: “It will hinder poorer countries’ ability to tackle and adapt to the climate emergency, and sour the UK’s diplomatic relationships in the run-up to the crucial Glasgow climate conference next year.”

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The Foreign Secretary is expected to make a Commons statement on Thursday setting out how the reduced aid budget will be used.

Whitehall sources insisted that by exercising rigorous control over the budget – now within the Foreign Office after DfID was scrapped – the Government will be able to deliver more with less.

But officials acknowledged that there was unrest on the Tory benches and the legislation could face a battle in Parliament.

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.