'Stark raving barmy': Yorkshire Labour MP hits out at Government plans to scale back jury trials
A Yorkshire MP has described plans to scale back jury trials as “the daftest idea any justice secretary of any political party could ever have come up with”.
Labour’s Karl Turner, MP for Hull East, has said he will break the whip for the first time since being elected in 2010 to vote against the Government’s plans to restrict juries for the most serious criminal cases.
Currently jury trials make up 3 per cent of cases but this will be curbed further as David Lammy confirmed they would be reserved for “indictable-only” offences such as murder and rape, and lesser “either-way” offences with a likely sentence of more than three years in prison.
Mr Lammy, who is also Deputy Prime Minister, told MPs reforms are “desperately needed” as victims face “agonising delays” in the system, with the crown court backlog projected to reach 100,000 by 2028.
“I’m clear that jury trials will continue to be the cornerstone of the system for the most serious offences,” he said.


“We must also be honest that this is a problem that has taken years to build up, it will take years to fix. The changes I’m proposing will require legislation, it will take time to implement. Our investment will also need time to have an effect.”
The suggestion to scrap more jury trials has faced opposition from MPs and legal professionals concerned over fairness, curtailing rights, and a lack of evidence the move will even help bring down the backlog.
Mr Turner, who describes Mr Lammy as a pal, told LBC: “On this issue he has got it incredibly badly wrong.
“The argument that this system is causing the backlog is just a complete lie.”
The former barrister added: “It is absolutely stark raving barmy.
“It's the Labour Party in government that comes along and does the worst thing they could ever do to the English criminal legal system that anybody could ever dream of.”
The Yorkshire MP said he had remonstrated with the Prime Minister, himself also a former barrister, over the reforms, warning he could have a welfare-style rebellion on his hands.
“I told him my fear is this is going to be a situation like the welfare benefit stuff where he marches Labour MPs up the hill and then he marches them back down again when the penny drops up. This can't get through Parliament."
Mr Turner’s remarks come as figures published yesterday showed the prison population is expected to reach 100,000 people in 2029.
The Ministry of Justice said the suggested increase was driven by several factors including a continued rise in police charges and prosecutions, more cases coming to court and increases in the numbers of offenders recalled to custody.
The impact of the Sentencing Bill currently going through Parliament, aimed at ending the prison capacity crisis in the long-term, is not included in the projection because it has not yet come into force.
The legislation includes plans for a Texas-inspired earned release scheme, where inmates who demonstrate good behaviour could be freed earlier, while those who break the rules will serve longer jail time.
