FT: Hull City 1-1 Stoke City
The Tigers had James Chester sent off after only 14 minutes but appeared on course to claim an unlikely win after Nikica Jelavic’s instinctive finish gave them the lead shortly before half-time.
Indeed, for much of the 76 minutes they played with a man disadvantage they were the better side, outpassing, outchasing and outworking a Potters team that lacked direction.
But they rescued a result, and a first point of the season, when Phil Bardsley’s angled shot ricocheted off the inside of the post, against goalkeeper Allan McGregor and was nudged over the line by the waiting Shawcross.
A point was arguably more than Mark Hughes’ side deserved for such a listless showing but Hull must surely have feared worse when they were asked to play the majority of the game at a numerical disadvantage.
Hull were eager to assert themselves in the opening minutes, looking to get on the front foot and attempting to target Bardsley at right-back.
Andrew Robertson was the chosen outlet and he began to find his range with a couple of teasing crosses from the left.
Yet despite Hull’s positive start, exemplified by the busy Stephen Quinn, Stoke were threatening on the break.
Their first warning came after only three minutes when Peter Odemwingie played in Mame Diouf.
He shook off Chester to leave himself clean through but was judged to have fouled the defender in the process.
Chester was not so lucky next time, when Livermore’s underhit back pass invited Glenn Whelan to charge at goal.
All the momentum lay with the Irishman, who was left in a heap by an outstretched leg that had denied a clear scoring chance.
Referee Jonathan Moss did not hesitate to produce the red card, leaving the hosts with a mountain to climb.
The tactical reshuffle was relatively simple, Ahmed Elmohamady and Robertson swapping wing-back to full-back and Tom Ince dropping deeper into midfield.
It was a system Stoke struggled to pick holes in despite their advantage.
Their were half-chances - an Odemwingie dribble into the area, Erik Pieters’ wayward drive - but the hosts were holding up well.
Hughes responded by sending on summer signing Bojan Krkic four minutes before half-time, with Whelan sacrificed, but he was unimpressive in Hull’s opener just seconds later.
Lacking the bite that Whelan would have offered, he allowed Tom Huddlestone to breeze past him before unleashing a low shot that Asmir Begovic could only palm back out.
Jelavic anticipated well, beat Marc Wilson to the ball and hooked home from a tight angle.
It was the least Hull’s battling response deserved and it was the hosts who ended the half pressing for a second as Stoke lost all semblance of calm.
Hughes’ half-time words seemed to have some effect, with his side much improved after the break.
McGregor was called on twice in as many minutes, saving low from Shawcross following a free-kick routine then diving in front of Diouf to smother a cross.
The respective managers quickly re-drew the battle lines, Hughes sending Peter Crouch on as a second striker and Steve Bruce replacing Ince with another defender in Liam Rosenior.
Stoke had their best chance yet when Bojan’s deft pass played in Crouch after 64 minutes but a clumsy touch allowed McShane to make a covering challenge.
The ball looped invitingly for Diouf but his cushioned header landed a yard wide.
Stoke’s final substitute, Charlie Adam, was into the game immediately, firing a 25-yarder that McGregor flicked over the crossbar.
The game was gradually building towards Stoke’s response but Hull did not seem liable to crack.
It took a wrongly-awarded throw-in and an unusal bounce of the ball to breach them, Bardsley hitting Bojan’s cross into the ground and watching it rear up and bounce off the frame of the goal.
McGregor, briefly disorientated, allowed it to come back off him instead of gathering it and Shawcross did just enough - his effort confirmed by goal-line technology.
There would no winner but Hull, ever game for the fight, ended the game bravely seeking one.